Skip to content

New York couple locked in savage ‘dogfight’ with pet rescue over ownership of foster pups 

See more of our coverage in your search results.

It’s a ruff story.

A New York couple is being accused of dognapping nine premier pooches — by a Westchester shelter owner — who herself is at the center of multiple complaints from previous clients.

The two parties are currently locked in a vicious dogfight over eight adorable boxer-shepherd puppies and their mom.

Kris Fuhr, who works in tech, and Sara Obstarczyk, a former pilates instructor, are suing Lisa Smith, 53, president and owner of A Good Dog Rescue, Inc., a Westchester-based nonprofit.

The couple claims in a lawsuit that Smith harassed them, doxxed them, caused them to get death threats, and forced them to uproot their lives when they decided to keep the nine dogs they fostered from her — when she demanded them back.

The couple says they felt obligated to keep the pups after concerns for their well-being in Smith’s custody.

Smith, whose organization claims to have saved more than 6,000 pooches since its inception in October 2018, filed a countersuit alleging they kidnapped the dogs — and that they remain hers.

Fuhr and Obstarczyk — a couple since September 2011 — told The Post the drama that has upended their lives all began when they answered a Facebook post in mid-January 2025 asking for emergency fosters for a dog named Paisley.

According to the lawsuit, on Jan. 10, 2025, Obstarczyk contacted Smith.

Obstarczyk, 45, was told that Paisley was taken, but Smith had a boxer-shepherd mix named Lily and her litter of 10 puppies, which were 3 weeks old, also in need of emergency care.

They decided to do it.

After clearing an 11-dog adoption with their landlord in their Tribeca building, Obstarczyk and Fuhr said, Smith asked minimal questions before sending over a single-page, unsigned foster agreement, according to the suit.

They decided to do it.

“We went from having never met her to her wanting to give us 11 of her animals in just a few hours of time,” 45-year-old Fuhr told The Post.

Nevertheless, on a freezing January morning, days later, Smith’s two young daughters transported the dogs to the couple’s apartment.

In her affidavit, Obstarczyk called the exchange “oddly transactional.”

“We did this out of the goodness of our hearts and for the well-being of the animals we were helping,” Fuhr told The Post of the couple spending thousands of dollars on food and supplies.

Two of the puppies were adopted quite quickly; eight remained with the couple, along with Lily.

It all started to go wrong when the puppies were a few months old.

According to the couple, Smith told them she had “an approved adopter in Westchester County” who was seeking a male dog, so Smith wanted “to pick up all the male dogs so this one adopter could meet them.”

Today's News.
For Conservatives.
Every Single Day.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
News Opt-in
(Optional) By checking this box you are opting in to receive news notifications from News Rollup. Text HELP for help, STOP to end. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Privacy Policy & Terms: textsinfo.com/PP